How do I get my first reviews on a new store?
Short answer
Ask every buyer the same way, once they've had time to use what they bought, and send a direct link so leaving a review takes a minute. Don't buy fake reviews, don't ask only the happy customers, and never tie a reward to a good rating. The FTC's rule, 16 CFR Part 465, makes fake and paid positive reviews illegal.
How to do it
A new store doesn't need a review app on day one. It needs a habit of asking, done the same way every time.
Ask every buyer, not just the happy ones.
Send the same request to everyone who bought, after delivery, once they've had time to use it. The FTC's guidance says asking only the customers you expect to be happy is a problem.
Make it one tap.
Put a direct link in the email or text. For Google, your Business Profile can give you a link or QR code that opens the review form. On your own store, link straight to the product's review form, not the home page.
Call your first customers yourself.
With your first ten or twenty orders you have time to pick up the phone. Fix anything that's wrong, then send them the same review link as everyone else, whatever they told you.
Only ask people who have used the product.
Don't ask before the order has arrived, and don't ask people who never bought.
Keep friends, family and staff out of it.
Under the FTC rule, insiders and family who review your business have to clearly disclose the connection. Google's policy prohibits conflict of interest reviews, and they can be removed. It isn't worth it.
Answer every review, including the bad ones.
Short, specific replies show a real person runs the store. Don't hide the negative ones. The FTC rule bars a business from suppressing negative reviews while implying the ones it shows are all it got.
What to do this week
Write one review request email and one text. Keep each to three or four sentences: thank them, ask how it's going, give the link. Set it to go out a set number of days after delivery, long enough that they've actually used the thing.
Then go through every order you've shipped so far and send the request by hand to each one. It's a short list, and the fastest way to your first reviews.
What it costs in time
Plan on an hour or two to write the request and set up the timing. After that, the ongoing cost is the phone calls and the replies, which is a few minutes per order while you're small.
What to measure
Track how many people you asked and how many left a review. That ratio tells you whether your timing and wording work. Change one thing at a time, like the delay after delivery.
Common mistakes
Asking before the product arrives.
A request that lands before delivery gets ignored or gets a review about shipping. Wait until they've used it.
Faking it or paying for good reviews.
Fake reviews are illegal under 16 CFR Part 465, and so is any incentive that depends on the review being positive or on what the reviewer says. Google's policy prohibits incentives for Google reviews at all. For a new store, the simple default is no incentive.
Filtering who gets asked.
Sending the link only to people who seemed pleased, or routing unhappy people somewhere else first, is exactly the kind of selective asking the FTC warns about.
How it looks in practice
In an online store
If you sell a $250 standing desk, set one email to go out two weeks after delivery to every buyer, with a direct link to the review form and no offer attached. Call the first few buyers to ask how assembly went. If one mentions a missing bolt, ship it that day, fix your packing checklist, and send that buyer the same review link as everyone else.
In a trade or service business
If you just went out on your own as an electrician, you need Google reviews. Don't hand the homeowner your phone to post one on the spot; a review from your device can look like a conflict of interest and get filtered. The day after the job, text every customer a thank you and the review link. Don't offer a discount on the next job for a review, since Google's policy prohibits it.
Where Purebrand fits, and where it does not
Reviews are strangers writing to strangers, and a new store starts with none. Purebrand adds a different kind of proof: on Shopify today, a shopper can get on a live Video Meeting with a Real Customer, someone verified by a real purchase who is compensated for their time. Trading text and video messages with a Real Customer is coming soon. It needs a few past buyers willing to talk, so it isn't a shortcut around your first sales, and it sits next to your reviews rather than replacing them.
Quick follow ups
Can I give a discount or gift card for a review?
Not for Google reviews, because Google's policy prohibits incentives for them. Under the FTC rule, an incentive can never depend on the review being positive or on what the reviewer says. Check each platform's own rules before you offer anything.
Can my family review my store?
Under the FTC rule, only if they clearly disclose that they're family. Google's policy prohibits conflict of interest reviews, and they can be removed. Skip it.
When did the FTC review rule take effect?
October 21, 2024. It lets courts impose civil penalties for knowing violations.
Sources
- 116 CFR Part 465: Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
- 2The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers
Federal Trade Commission
- 3
- 4Tips to get more reviews
Google Business Profile Help
