How can I tell if a review is fake?
Short answer
Look at patterns, not single reviews. Fake reviews tend to be vague, arrive in bursts on the same few days, come from profiles with no other history, and miss details anyone who used the product would mention. No single sign proves anything, but several together are a strong reason to trust that page less.
How to do it
You can check this in a few minutes, whether you're vetting a supplier, sizing up another seller's page or reading reviews of your own business.
Read the details, not the stars.
Real reviews mention specific things: the sizing ran small, the install took two hours, the color was darker than the photo. Fake ones lean on general praise that could describe anything.
Check the dates.
Sort by newest and scroll. A pile of reviews landing in the same few days, then silence, is a pattern worth noticing, especially right after a product launch.
Look at the reviewer.
Click through where you can. A profile with one review, or dozens of glowing reviews for unrelated businesses in different cities, is a warning sign.
Compare the wording.
Several reviews that repeat the same phrases, or spell out the full product name word for word, often came from the same source.
Read the middle and the bottom.
Three star reviews are often the most honest. If a page has only perfect scores and nothing in between, ask why.
Check whether it was a purchase.
Where a platform marks verified buyers, see how many of the reviews carry that mark. It isn't proof either way, but it helps.
What to do this week
Read through your own reviews with this list. If you find ones that look fake, report them to the platform. If you find reviews from staff or family that don't disclose the connection, ask them to disclose it or take them down.
Then pick one supplier or partner you rely on and read their reviews the same way.
What it costs in time
Checking one product page takes five to ten minutes. Auditing your own reviews once a quarter takes an hour or so for a small store.
What to measure
Keep a short log of reviews you reported and what the platform did. Over time it shows whether a problem is one bad actor or a pattern. For your own store, measure how many reviews come from buyers you can match to a real order.
Common mistakes
Treating one sign as proof.
A short review from a new account can be perfectly real. Look for several signs together before you decide.
Writing reviews to balance things out.
If another seller's page looks stuffed, don't answer with fake reviews of your own. Fake reviews, and reviews paid for or rewarded for being positive, are illegal under the FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465. Any incentive must never depend on what the reviewer says.
Calling out a reviewer in public.
Accusing a real customer of being fake in your reply goes badly when you're wrong. Report it quietly and reply politely.
How it looks in practice
In an online store
If you're choosing a supplier for a new product line and their listing shows a wall of perfect reviews all posted in one week, all saying "great quality, fast shipping", order a sample before you order stock. Read the lower scored reviews for what actually goes wrong.
In a trade or service business
If you're a general contractor hiring an HVAC sub, glowing online reviews aren't enough. Ask for the addresses of two recent jobs and a phone number for each homeowner. A past customer you can call beats any number of reviews you can't check.
Where Purebrand fits, and where it does not
On Shopify today, Purebrand lets a shopper get on a live Video Meeting with a Real Customer of that store, someone verified by a real purchase and compensated for their time. Trading text and video messages with a Real Customer is coming soon. A person on video can answer a follow up question in a way a written review can't. It won't clean up fake reviews anywhere else, and it doesn't replace reading reviews.
Quick follow ups
Are fake reviews illegal?
Yes. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, which took effect October 21, 2024, prohibits fake reviews and lets courts impose civil penalties for knowing violations.
Can I get a fake review of my business removed?
Report it through the platform's own tools. Google's review policy lists the kinds of content it removes, including fake engagement and conflicts of interest.
Is a review from a free sample fake?
Not necessarily, but the connection should be disclosed, and the free product can't depend on the review being positive.
Sources
- 116 CFR Part 465: Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
- 2The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers
Federal Trade Commission
- 3
