Why they didn't buy

How do I find out why customers didn't buy from me?

Short answer

Ask the people who almost bought, as close to the moment they left as you can, and let them answer in their own words instead of picking from a list. Then match what they say against where your analytics show them leaving. The numbers show where people quit. Only people can tell you why.

How to do it

This is a diagnosis, not a feedback program. You're hunting for one reason at one step, so do these in order and let each one aim the next.

  1. Find the step where people quit.

    Before you ask why, find out where. The conversion breakdown in Shopify's behavior reports (Analytics, then Reports) shows sessions, sessions that added to cart, sessions that reached checkout and sessions that finished. Pick the step with the steepest fall. That's the only step you work on for now.

  2. Name what usually breaks at that step.

    A drop before the cart usually means the product page left a doubt open. A drop between cart and checkout often means a cost the buyer didn't expect. A drop inside checkout points at trust or friction. Write down your guess.

  3. Walk that step as a buyer.

    Open the page on your phone and try to buy as a stranger would. Write down every question you'd want answered and every moment you'd hesitate.

  4. Ask one open question at the exit.

    Put a single question on the page where people leave: what stopped you from buying today? Use a text box, not a list of options, so you hear their reason instead of your own guesses.

  5. Talk to five people who got close.

    If you have emails from people who started a checkout and left, reach out to five of them this week. Say who you are, say you're not selling anything, and ask what got in the way.

  6. Watch sessions that ended at that step.

    Recordings show where people hesitate, scroll back and forth, or tap something that isn't a button. Microsoft's FAQ describes Clarity as a free recording tool that works with Shopify.

  7. Write a one line diagnosis, then test it.

    Finish the sentence: people leave at this step because of this. Make one change that answers it and compare full weeks before and after. If the drop doesn't move, go back to what people told you.

What to do this week

Open your conversion breakdown and write down the single biggest drop. Walk that step on your phone, add the one question survey there, and send five short, personal notes to people who left checkout.

What it costs in time

Plan on about an hour to pull the report and set up the survey, then twenty minutes a day for a week to read answers, watch recordings and reply to people who write back. Then give your fix two full weeks.

What to measure

Measure the drop at the step you're fixing, before and after your change, in full weeks so one odd day doesn't fool you. Also count how often each reason shows up in what people tell you. If the top reason fades and the drop shrinks, your diagnosis was right.

Common mistakes

  • Asking with multiple choice.

    You'll get your own guesses handed back to you. Open text is messier and far more useful.

  • Asking too late.

    A survey sent two weeks after someone left gets silence. Ask on the page, or within a day.

  • Fixing everything at once.

    If you change price, photos and shipping in the same week, you won't know what worked. Fix the top reason, then measure.

How it looks in practice

In an online store

If you sell a $900 espresso machine and get plenty of carts but few orders, the drop sits between cart and checkout. Walk it yourself and ask the people who left. If the same worry keeps coming back, like how much daily cleaning the machine needs, that's your diagnosis. Add a plain cleaning section with photos.

In a trade or service business

If you install HVAC systems and a lot of homeowners you quote never call back, the drop is between quote and signed job. Call three of them a week later and ask what decided it. If they mention how slowly your quote arrived, fix that before you touch price.

Where Purebrand fits, and where it does not

Purebrand covers one part of this live. On Shopify today, a shopper can join a Video Meeting with a Real Customer, someone verified by a real purchase from your store who is compensated for their time, and ask the questions your page didn't answer.

It won't replace your survey, your reports or your own calls, and it only helps shoppers who are willing to talk. Text and video messages with a Real Customer are coming soon, and so are platforms other than Shopify.

Book a demo

Quick follow ups

Can I find out why without asking anyone?

Only partly. Reports tell you where people leave and recordings show how they behave. Neither tells you what they were thinking. One short question to a real person closes that gap.

What if the reason turns out to be price?

Check whether it's the price itself or the surprise. A shipping cost that appears on the last screen feels like a price problem. So does a page that never explains why the product costs what it does.

Is it pushy to email people who left checkout?

One short, personal note asking what got in the way is fair. Keep it to one message and don't turn it into a pitch. If they answer, thank them, whether or not they buy.

Sources

  1. 1
    Behavior reports

    Shopify Help Center

  2. 2
    Clarity FAQ

    Microsoft Learn