Why they didn't buy

How do I collect customer feedback for a small store?

Short answer

Build a small system with four inputs: a short survey after purchase, tags on every support email, the reason behind every return, and a few customer calls a month. Put it all in one sheet and review it once a month. Pick one fix each time, make it, and check whether that complaint shows up less.

How to do it

Feedback works when it runs on a schedule. Set up the inputs once, then give it one fixed hour a month.

  1. Send one survey after delivery.

    A few weeks after the order arrives, send two questions: how is it going, and what would you change? Free text, not star ratings. Keep it private and separate from any review request.

  2. Tag your support inbox.

    Make five or six labels, like sizing, shipping, setup, quality and price. Every email gets one label when you answer it. Tagging takes seconds and turns a messy inbox into something you can count.

  3. Capture a reason for every return.

    Ask for the reason in the return email or form, in the customer's words where you can. A return is the most expensive feedback you'll ever get, so don't let it arrive without one.

  4. Talk to a few customers a month.

    Put two or three calls on the calendar. Pick a mix: a repeat buyer, a first time buyer, someone who returned. Ask open questions and mostly listen.

  5. Pour it into one sheet.

    Survey answers, tag counts, return reasons and call notes all go in the same place, with the date and the product. One sheet beats four tools nobody opens.

  6. Hold a monthly review.

    Same day each month, one hour. Look at what came up most, pick one fix, and write down what you expect to change. Next month, check whether it did.

What to do this week

Create the inbox labels and tag the last two weeks of email. Then write your two question survey and set it to go out after delivery. Put the first monthly review on your calendar before you close the laptop.

What it costs in time

Setup is an afternoon. After that, tagging adds almost nothing to answering email, the calls take an hour or two a month, and the review takes one hour. The system costs more when you skip the review, because the sheet just grows.

What to measure

For each tag and return reason, track the count per month, per product. When you make a fix, watch that one line. Also track how many people answer the survey, and shorten it if the number falls. Measure this in your own store rather than chasing someone else's benchmark.

Common mistakes

  • Collecting and never reviewing.

    A sheet nobody reads is worse than none, because it makes you feel like you're listening. The monthly hour is the system.

  • Fixing five things at once.

    If you change five things in a month, you won't know which one worked. One fix per review.

  • Too many tags.

    Twenty labels means nobody tags consistently. Start with a handful and split one only when it gets crowded.

  • Mixing feedback with review requests.

    Don't use a private survey to decide who gets asked for a public review. The FTC's guidance warns against asking only the happy ones.

How it looks in practice

In an online store

If you sell handmade leather bags, tag every support email and log every return reason. If the monthly review shows sizing at the top two months running, add a photo of the bag being carried and the inside dimensions to the page, then watch the sizing count the next month.

In a trade or service business

If you run a plumbing business, send a two question text a week after each job and tag every callback by cause. Once a month, sit down with the sheet. If callbacks keep tracing to one kind of fitting, change the part or the way the crew installs it.

Where Purebrand fits, and where it does not

On Shopify today, Purebrand puts a shopper on a live Video Meeting with a Real Customer, a past buyer of your store verified by a real purchase and compensated for their time. Trading text and video messages with a Real Customer is coming soon. That gives shoppers someone to ask before they buy. It's free to install and you pay only on attributed revenue.

It doesn't replace the system above. Text and video messages with a Real Customer are coming soon, not live yet, and platforms other than Shopify are coming soon too.

Book a demo

Quick follow ups

Which tool should I use for the survey?

Whatever your email or store platform already offers is fine to start. The questions and the monthly review matter more than the tool.

How often should I survey the same customer?

Once per order is plenty. If someone buys every month, skip the survey on most orders so it doesn't feel like a chore.

Should staff see the feedback sheet?

Yes, anyone who answers customers or packs orders. They often spot the cause of a complaint faster than you will.

Sources