How do I reduce returns in my online store?
Short answer
Find out why each item comes back, then fix the expectation that caused it. Many returns start on the product page: wrong size, color that looked different, a feature the buyer assumed. Collect a return reason every time, fix the top reason first, and answer fit and use questions before checkout, not after delivery.
How to do it
Returns are customers telling you what your page got wrong. Listen first, then fix.
Require a return reason.
Make the return form ask why, with a free text box next to the dropdown if your returns setup allows it, or ask in the return confirmation email. A list of options only tells you which of your guesses they clicked.
Sort returns by product and reason.
Put every return in a sheet: product, variant, reason in the customer's words. One or two products often cause most of the trouble. Start there.
Fix the page for the top reason.
If it's size, add real measurements and a fit note. If it's color, add photos in daylight. If it's "not what I expected," show the product in use and say plainly what it doesn't do.
Answer questions before checkout.
Read your support inbox for questions people asked before buying. Each one is a return waiting to happen for the buyers who didn't ask. Put the answers on the page.
Check packaging and shipping damage.
If items arrive broken or scuffed, that's a packing problem, not a page problem. Fix the box.
Call a few people who returned.
A five minute call to someone who sent a product back often tells you more than a hundred dropdown answers. Ask what they expected and what they got.
What to do this week
Export your returns from the last three months. Sort by product. Read every reason for your most returned product and rewrite its page to answer the top one. Add a free text reason field to your return form, or ask for the reason in the return confirmation email.
What it costs in time
About two hours to sort returns and fix the first page. Then thirty minutes a week reading new return reasons. Fixing one page is faster than processing the returns it would have caused.
What to measure
Track return rate by product each month: returns divided by units sold. Measure this in your own store before and after each page change, comparing full months, not days.
Track reasons too. If "too small" drops after you add measurements, the fix worked even if the total moves slowly.
Common mistakes
Making returns harder.
A painful return process may cut returns, and it also cuts the next order. Fix the cause, not the exit.
Only looking at totals.
One overall return rate hides the one product that causes the trouble. Break it down.
Overselling on the page.
Copy that promises more than the product does wins the sale and loses it back as a return. Say what it doesn't do.
How it looks in practice
In an online store
Say you sell $80 rain jackets and they come back as "too small." You add chest and sleeve measurements for each size, a note that it fits close and to size up for layers, and a photo of the jacket over a sweater. Then you watch next month's return reasons.
In a trade or service business
Say you run an HVAC business that sells furnace filters online, and people send them back because they ordered the wrong size. You add a line telling buyers to check the size printed on the old filter's edge, with a photo showing where to find it.
Where Purebrand fits, and where it does not
Many returns come from a question the buyer never got to ask. On Shopify today, Purebrand lets a shopper get on a live Video Meeting with a Real Customer, a past buyer verified by a real purchase who is compensated for their time, and ask what they'd want to know before buying. Trading text and video messages with a Real Customer is coming soon. The store installs it free and pays only on attributed revenue.
It won't fix packaging damage or a weak product, and it doesn't run outside Shopify yet; other platforms are coming soon.
Quick follow ups
What is a normal return rate?
It depends heavily on what you sell. Don't chase someone else's number. Track your own by product and work it down.
Should I charge for returns?
It may reduce returns and may also reduce orders. If you try it, watch both, and fix the product pages first.
Does free shipping cause more returns?
It can make buying on a guess easier. The fix is a page that removes the guess, not taking away shipping.
